Teaching Diversity 

Teaching with medieval objects not only reaches the everyday experiences and diverse identities of historical actors, but also gives students with different learning styles and abilities the opportunity to succeed in the classroom. Medieval history has been traditionally organized around the religious and lay elites who produced the bulk of our surviving documents. The interdisciplinary study of archaeology and art broadens this evidence to include underrepresented groups of different races, faiths, and economic backgrounds who left behind fewer surviving texts. Students in my medieval and early modern core survey class examine the often marginalized figures of women and the poor as well as medieval pagans, Jews, and Muslims. They study twelfth-century accounts of blood libel alongside the depictions of Jews in the Carew-Poyntz Book of Hours to understand how Jewish communities became targets of racial and religious violence. They also learn, however, how Christian rulers would gladly ally with Muslim and pagan leaders against fellow Christians to achieve their political and economic goals.

In my “Dark Age” identities course, students explore how race and gender are constructed in different Mediterranean cultures through objects and architectures c. 400 – c. 1100. Burial evidence in particular allows us to examine how such identities are carefully curated by those left behind, from the bent bones of an African woman buried in northern England, to the masculine Romanized grave goods of barbarian leaders on the borders of the Roman Empire.

6th- to 8th-century pilgrim flask of St. Menas (Egypt) https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/447995

6th- to 8th-century pilgrim flask of St. Menas (Egypt) https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/447995

One of the central arguments of my research is the diversity of medieval Christianities and the false sense of premodern unity encouraged by the term “Christendom.” This is a word often used to define a medieval world of Christians versus “others,” misrepresenting a society where religious and racial categories were fluid and shifting. I routinely emphasize to my students that the Middle Ages with its diverse communities of Christians, Muslims, and Jews was a far more complicated and wider world than we often imagine. This is an increasingly important message for students today at a moment when modern white supremacists portray medieval Europe as a uniform white civilization. Students from underrepresented groups deserve to see people like themselves in the past because they were there. Our larger historical narratives of European history must reflect that.

I designed one assignment on the early modern slave trade that encouraged students to learn how to approach global history through different types of sources. They explored an online archival database of the Atlantic slave trade, slavevoyages.org, and read individual slave narratives as well as book chapters on the Middle Passage. One of my students from Barbados found a slave ship in the database that had sailed from West Africa to Barbados at the same time that her ancestors had made that journey. The captain of the ship had her last name. This slim reference resulted in a powerful personal moment which instantly connected her history to that of men and women in the past.

My use of material and digital evidence in the classroom consciously integrates—rather than simply accommodates—students who learn best from different forms of media as well as those with visual impairments. Students have consistently praised my use of different kinds of historical evidence and said their opportunities to leave the classroom for interactions with historical objects and architectures in person was the most valuable learning experience of the course. Hands-on interaction with medieval objects in a museum or 3D-printed replicas also allow students with visual limitations to experience in a tangible way aspects of medieval life that are otherwise inaccessible. My students complete a variety of types of assignments—from written papers to image analyses and creating online exhibitions—to bring their best analytical skills to bear on the diverse lives of historical people and to rethink what they thought they knew about premodern history.